Actio! Improving student presentations through peer feedback
Introduction
This project develops a scientifically grounded peer feedback model for actio, the delivery of a presentation. Clear, evidence-based guidance on presentation delivery is lacking, even though presentation skills are important in today’s knowledge society and increasingly relevant as higher education moves towards more oral assessment in the age of AI. Better feedback can help students deliver more persuasive presentations and give lecturers a sound basis for teaching presentation skills.
What is the reason for the project?
Oral presentation skills are important in a knowledge society, where effective knowledge transfer is crucial for prosperity and well-being. With the rise of generative AI, higher education institutions are moving towards more oral assessment, placing students’ authentic performance at the centre.
Yet there is no clear, scientifically grounded understanding of what effective presentation delivery involves. Lecturers and students therefore often rely on intuitive advice or guidance spread across different sources. This project aims to address that gap by establishing a well-founded set of presentation techniques and translating them into practical feedback and assessment tools for higher education.
Which problem does the project address?
The project addresses the lack of clear, evidence-based guidance on effective presentation delivery. This makes it difficult for lecturers to teach presentation skills in a structured way and for students to know how to improve their delivery. The project aims to provide a stronger basis for feedback and assessment, helping students become more persuasive presenters and supporting the use of presentations in oral assessment.
How does the project team approach this?
The project uses a mixed-methods approach to improve students’ presentation delivery, also known as actio or pronuntiatio. First, a corpus analysis of Dutch and Flemish books on presentation advice identifies the most prominent techniques. A panel of experts in rhetoric, communication and higher education is then consulted using the Delphi method to assess and prioritise these techniques.
Through a design-based research process, the findings are translated into a prototype feedback model. This model is tested iteratively in different curricula to develop a practical tool for higher education that is grounded in empirical evidence and theory.
The project is led by Maarten van der Meulen, a presentation skills expert in the Master’s in Strategic Communication who is pursuing a PhD at Leiden University. The supervisory team includes Jaap de Jong, Professor of Journalism and New Media at Leiden University; Martijn Wackers, coordinator and lecturer in communication skills at Delft University of Technology; and Migchiel van Diggelen, Professor of Design-Based Education at NHL Stenden.
The project also connects with DBE, where students learn through iterative design, reflection and improvement. Peer feedback supports this process by helping students improve their own presentations while developing their feedback skills, reflection and professional communication.
What are the main or preliminary results?
The research has mapped the presentation techniques recommended in Dutch and Flemish advice books. A review of the 20 most prominent books identified 64 techniques, ranging from posture and gestures to pace, volume and pauses.
The recommendations sometimes contradict one another and vary considerably. This makes it difficult for lecturers to gain a clear overview of the techniques and teach them effectively. In the next phase, experts will be consulted using the Delphi method to build consensus on a curriculum of presentation techniques for higher education. The results will help education professionals draw on recommendations that have broad support.
Project partners
Leiden University Centre for Linguistics, Leiden University
Institute for Language and Academic Skills, Delft University of Technology